Could AI really replace teachers? Not so fast, say the experts

by Finn Patraic

When you buy through links on our site, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. However, this does not influence our evaluations.

While unsatisfied American parents are looking for education alternatives following the frustrations of the pandemic era with the status quo, the role of the teacher evolves quickly, certain private schools redefining the human element within the classrooms responsible for technologies.

At the Alpha school in Brownsville, Texas, being part of a Increasing chain of private institutions that use artificial intelligence To teach basic subjects, instructors act as pre-K facilitators through the eighth year students who work to master 30-minute personalized sessions.

The teachers of the Alpha network, which develops in New York, Houston, Phoenix and elsewhere this fall, aim to supervise and motivate students while giving a feeling of autonomy from the preschool.

“In the public school, you really teach a cover lesson, and you hope and cross your fingers that children hang on,” said Samantha Hilton, instructor of the Brownsville d'Alpha campus, Samantha Nowsweek During a visit to his campus.

“But you have children who are late and they do not understand what you say, you have brilliant children and on the point and then you have advanced children and who are bored.”

Hilton claims that the tailor -made Alpha program allows students to become “unlimited”, creating individualized learning silos in each class.

“Public schools must have an open mind and start to take advantage of the power of AI and individualized learning models,” she said. “It would help students learn more quickly, more efficiently and I think they would be more confident and loved their school career.”

The role of teachers

While some experts said previously Nowsweek The condensed and digital focused model should cause discussions in public districts nationally, most think that educators will not be replaced by AI – at least any time.

Alpha 2
The students of the Alpha school in Brownsville, Texas, are personalized personalized learning sessions and fueled by AI while instructors seek to promote emotional growth and a passion for education. (Newsweek)

Colleen Hroncich, political analyst at the Center for Educational Liberty of the Libertarian Cato Institute, congratulated the individualized approach of Alpha which allows students to finish the lessons in a few hours, releasing their afternoons for workshops on life skills. But teachers are always likely to play a major role in almost all educational environments, she said.

“Having this personal connection will always be very important for a large number of parents,” said Hroncich. “Admittedly, some will prefer the effectiveness of the model, but even in a school like Alpha, they have guides there, they have adults there. So maybe their role is a little different from a teacher-they do not stand in front of a classroom and their brand-but they are still there to support children, supervise them and establish relationships.”

Whether in public or private schools, Hroncich said that educators should realize that “a single size does not correspond to everyone”, with variable paths opening the way to the success of each student.

“The ability to individualize and promote control over the time of the siege and let children progress in the content while measuring and adapting their learning, I think it is very beneficial,” said Hroncich.

“It was a little in preparation, but it certainly seems that the lights have jumped recently and that the schools would do well to see which part they can integrate even in a conventional school to try to reach children at this more individualized level.”

Alpha campuse staff was previously known as “guides” instead of teachers, but now assumes the most typical class nickname.

“They voted a few weeks ago to avoid confusion because teachers are still involved with the student on several levels (socio-emotional learning, motivation, objectives, support) in addition to” teaching “them life skills,” said Alpha communications director Anna Davlanttes, Nowsweek In a statement on Thursday.

The Alpha website has always identified staff as “guides” on Friday, but says they differ from traditional instructors.

“With support powered by AI, they focus on emotional growth, life skills and promote a passion for learning – give students time and freedom to prosper,” reads the site.

Regardless of what Alpha students call adults in the room, public school districts at national level could reduce part of his innovative method, according to Michael Van Beek, director of research at Mackinac Center for Public Policy, based in Michigan, which describes as a “free market” research institute.

Alpha school
After condensed morning learning sessions, Alpha students spend their afternoons perfecting critical life skills such as public speaking, financial literacy or physical activities. (Newsweek)

“Personalize the study program and allow students to progress in different fields at different steps depending on their information mastery – which would change the situation for the way public schools generally work,” said Van Beek.

“The conventional model is to provide instructions to the whole group at a time, then give them a test with high issues if they have kept the material, then you advance.”

Van Beek said that it is difficult to prove the true effectiveness of the Alpha model, which promises that students will learn twice as fast as their peers in just two hours of teaching per day, but the expansion of the private channel seems to indicate that parents are satisfied.

“It is difficult to separate what is promotional material in relation to information,” said Van Beek. “Obviously, these schools are marked with parents because they are fully counting on parents who choose to register and pay for tuition fees.”

Alpha is part of a wide variety of alternative education models sought by American parents who want more contribution and control, but its ascent should not be considered a death knell for teachers, Van Beek said.

“I had the impression that teachers are absolutely essential to what they do as a school, but they have a slightly different role,” said Van Beek. “They are less focused on teaching provision and more focused on the student's assistance to succeed. The role of teachers at (Alpha) is slightly different from the role in conventional public schools, but I do not think that we need it less – or that the role is less important.”

Alpha teachers seem to be used more as a “support staff” dedicated to the empowerment of self -sufficient students, added Van Beek.

“Many teachers I know, that's what motivates them, that's what they like to be a teacher-the relationships they have with students,” he said. “It is not really the content they teach; it is more relationships.”

Parents are looking for alternatives

Van Beek expects that a wide variety of unorthodox models like Alpha continues to prosper because an overwhelming majority of parents are not satisfied with the overall state of schooling. Only six percent of the respondents qualified the United States's education system “very good”, much less than the 23% which judged it “very bad”, According to a Yougov survey carried out in November.

“A little bad” led all the answers to 26%.

Respondents also had mixed feelings about educational systems in their local communities, 29% describing them as “a little good”, compared to 19% who declared the opposite, the ballot of more than 2,200 American adults.

“Parents want more choices when it comes to educating their children,” said Van Beek, referring to a growing interest in charter schools, good schools and other public-private programs.

“This is probably part of this wider trend, so I expect more alternative private models educating students and many of these models will focus on the empowerment of parents.”

Trump signs an executive decree
President Trump signed seven decrees related to education on April 23, including a policy to advance artificial intelligence skills among American young people.

SOMODEVILLA / GETTY Images chip

Alpha's attempt to revolutionize education intervenes in the midst of a new federal push to integrate AI into class K-12 and beyond. President Trump signed an executive decree last week which aspires to promote “fundamental knowledge and skills” among young people to use and create the next generation of technologies.

The directive also created the White House working group on AI education and requires that the Ministry of Education has secretary Linda McMahon To prioritize the use of AI in discretionary grant programs for teacher training.

“Education should prepare students for success in life, which means that American classrooms must better align their activities to respond to requests for accelerating innovation and rapidly evolving workforce,” McMahon said in a statement last week.

“While artificial intelligence reshape all industrial sector, it is of vital importance that the next generation of students is ready to take advantage of this technology in all aspects of their professional life.

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.